You Can't Punish A Child Into Feeling Safe At School – So Why Are We Trying?

1 hour ago 9

Rommie Analytics

Almost one in five pupils in England is persistently absent, compared with around one in 10 before the pandemic.

Current debates focus on how to get children back into classrooms. But perhaps we should be asking why so many are struggling to attend?

Reasons are complex. Children with special educational needs and disabilities (SEND) and those experiencing mental health difficulties are disproportionately likely to be absent from school.

Yet rates of childhood mental health difficulties have increased, and growing numbers of pupils with SEND are being educated in mainstream schools. In 2026, the number of pupils with Education, Health and Care Plans (EHCPs) attending mainstream schools rose by 16.9%, while specialist provision has struggled to keep pace with demand.

Schools are therefore supporting an increasingly complex range of needs, often without sufficient resources or specialist expertise.

Attitudes may be changing too. Parents are more aware of children’s emotional wellbeing and less willing to force a visibly distressed child into school.

We increasingly encourage young people to think independently, be critical consumers of information and recognise their emotional needs, yet still expect them to fit into an education system that requires high levels of compliance and is usually very structured and assessment-driven.

Perhaps it’s time to question the relative uniformity of that system.

One in five children are persistently absent – perhaps it's time to ask what's wrong with our schools.One in five children are persistently absent – perhaps it's time to ask what's wrong with our schools.

What needs to change

Children have enormously diverse needs, yet most are expected to follow the same curriculum, timetable and approach to learning.

Greater flexibility, both within schools and through a wider range of educational options, could give families more opportunities to find an environment in which their child can thrive, rather than expecting every child to adapt to the same model. 

Crucially, we must challenge the assumption that school avoidance is simply a behavioural choice.

For children experiencing emotionally based school non-attendance, school can trigger overwhelming anxiety and physiological stress. Their nervous systems may respond as though the environment is unsafe, even without an immediate threat.

These responses cannot simply be overridden through willpower or punishment. Yet parental fines and rewards for perfect attendance do nothing to address why school feels impossible for some children.

One potentially important factor remains underexplored: the sensory environment of schools themselves.

Imagine crowded corridors, noisy classrooms, harsh artificial lighting and constant visual stimulation, often with few opportunities to self-regulate through physical movement.

For children with sensory sensitivities, these everyday experiences may contribute to heightened stress. Research has identified associations between sensory sensitivities and mental health difficulties, particularly among autistic children.

At the Institute for the Science of Early Years and Youth (ISEY), our research institute at the University of East London (UEL), we are seeking funding to investigate whether school sensory environments contribute to children’s physiological stress and school avoidance, and whether environmental adaptations could help.

Sensory overload will not explain every child’s difficulties. But aspects of the physical environment offer a potentially useful lever for change: unlike many other factors, it’s something schools can change relatively quickly.

But schools cannot solve this crisis alone. They need adequate funding, specialist support and time. 

Parents must be listened to, not blamed. For families watching their children struggle, school absence is not a lifestyle choice; it can be deeply distressing.

And research needs to explore the underlying reasons for absence and question whether an education system with roots in the Victorian era still meets the needs of children today.

Our understanding of children’s developing brains has advanced enormously since then. Research in neuroscience, psychology and education has transformed what we know about attention, stress, learning and the environments in which children thrive. Surely it’s time to use that knowledge to rethink what education itself could look like?

We cannot punish children into feeling safe at school. We recognise that children have different strengths, needs and ways of learning. So, why do we still offer so little variety in how we educate them?

Professor Sam Wass and Dr Gemma Goldenberg are from the Institute for the Science of Early years and Youth (ISEY), University of East London (UEL).

Read Entire Article