I think about the Mitchell and Webb line that says love involves “two people who are a little bit deluded in each other’s favour” quite often – it’s true, isn’t it?
But when it comes to our self-perception, this bias gets more complicated. Most of us don’t have an accurate perception of our own attractiveness; more conventionally beautiful people rate themselves as less good-looking, and vice versa.
And while a mathematically impossible 65% of Americans think they’re smarter than average, this belief wasn’t evenly shared: men and younger people were more likely than women and/or older respondents to see themselves as unusually clever.
Meanwhile, a phenomenon known as the “liking gap” might explain a more negative self-perception: thinking you’re worse than you are at talking to new people.
What is the “liking gap”?
The term comes from a 2018 paper that involved five studies. In the first one, researchers asked 34 students to chat for five minutes – they were given icebreakers.
Secondly, 84 other students spoke to a new person for five minutes about whatever they wanted. In the third, longer study, researchers asked both the general public and students to pair up with a stranger and chat for 45 minutes.
The fourth and fifth studies involved participants in “real-world” scenarios, like entreprenur workshops and first-year Yale University dormitories. For all of the studies, after the conversation ended, each participant was asked to rate how well they thought they and their conversational partner came off.
A broad trend appeared across all five situations: people thought their partner disliked them a lot more than the stranger’s report actually suggested.
“People systematically underestimated how much their conversation partners liked them and enjoyed their company,” wrote the study authors.
This discrepancy, called the “liking gap”, was greater among shy people in the first study, too. The more bashful the participant, the less they thought strangers liked them.
Meanwhile, in the third study, the researchers noticed an “enjoyment gap” (where participants underestimated how much their partner enjoyed talking to them), too.
Most people take a “dismal” view of meeting strangers
The study authors continued to say that when people think about how rewarding meeting a new person will be, their predictions are “pretty dismal.
“So whereas speakers are thinking that they have failed to live up to their ideal, listeners are thinking that it could have been much worse, and this different standard of comparison for oneself and for others may well be one reason that people underestimate how much their conversation partners enjoy their company.”
An analysis of the first study suggested that when we talk to a stranger, we’re too worried about how we come across to notice signs of enjoyment or hints that the listener likes us.
“Our studies suggest that after people have conversations, they are liked more than they know,” the paper concludes.





Bengali (Bangladesh) ·
English (United States) ·