New PBS Documentary Explores the History of Criminal Justice in the U.S.

1 hour ago 3

Rommie Analytics

Black and white photo portraits | PBS/Fatima Ruiz.

A new four-episode PBS documentary series, Crime and Punishment in America, debuts tonight and offers a deeply researched and engaging history of the country's efforts to create a fair and humane justice system.

Written, directed, and produced by Lynn Novick and executive produced by Ken Burns, the documentary explores one of the most interesting but lesser-explored angles of our country's history. Like Reason's recent cover story on the history of American prisons, the documentary recognizes that the question of what criminal punishment in a constitutional republic should look like has been, outside of the problem of race, perhaps the country's most consequential and enduring debate over the last 250 years.

America was in fact where the modern penitentiary was created in the early 19th century, in an effort to move away from the public punishments and frequent executions that the nascent American states had inherited from England's criminal code. In an interview with Reason, Novick says the fact that the penitentiary was a relatively recent invention was one of the most surprising things she learned during her research.

"I just couldn't really quite believe it, that this thing that seems so normal to us and has always been here—the prison, a place where you send people who have committed a crime for a period of time—that construct really didn't exist," Novick says.

The first generation of American prison reformers had noble intentions, but they also had an oversized confidence in their theories that resulted in macabre and fatal experiments with extreme solitary confinement. Novick says that one of her favorite quotes in the series comes from historian Rebecca McLennan, who says that the Founding Fathers had "a narcissistic self-regard that they could perform surgery on the souls of men."

The first wave of American prisons failed spectacularly, and the subsequent waves would continue failing in 40- to 50-year cycles, as the national mood swung back and forth between disgust over prison scandals and anxiety and outrage over crime. 

The series features PBS' instantly recognizable documentary style of combining voluminous archival materials, A-list voice acting, immersive sound editing, and interviews with historians and firsthand sources to lead viewers through the historical arc of a big subject. The series features a who's-who of major figures in criminal justice over the past 50 years, from civil rights lawyer Bryan Stevenson to Philadelphia District Attorney Larry Krasner to former California Gov. Jerry Brown, as well as former correctional officers and inmates. 

One preview episode shared with Reason, "Episode IV: Getting Tough on Crime," begins with the infamous Attica prison riot in 1971 and moves through the passage of the Rockefeller drug laws and other harsh mandatory minimum sentences, the boom in prison construction during the 1980s, the creation of the victims' rights movement, through the tough-on-crime 1990s.

The documentary style is particularly effective in the case of more recent events, like the Attica riot and the retaking of the prison by state police, which left 30 incarcerated men and nine hostages dead. One of the Attica negotiators recalls in an interview with the filmmakers that, when the negotiating team was pulled out, many of the inmates, sensing that the standoff was only going to end one way, started handing him pieces of paper with phone numbers of loved ones to call if they died.

The biggest challenge for the series is that criminal justice intersects with so much of American history that there is too much material to conceivably cover. At times the documentary zips through sections that could be entire episodes, such as the failure of prohibition, the creation of Japanese internment camps during WWII, and the criminalization of abortion pre-Roe.

Still, Novick, who previously collaborated with Burns on The Vietnam War, Jazz, and Baseball, has a sure hand, and the depth of research and excellent interviews keep the material compelling, even for viewers familiar with many of the incidents the series covers. The story of how America created the modern prison system, maintained it despite its repeated failures, and exported it to the rest of the world is rarely told, though. For many viewers, Crime and Punishment in America will be an eye-opening look into some of the darker corners of American history.

The post New PBS Documentary Explores the History of Criminal Justice in the U.S. appeared first on Reason Magazine.

Read Entire Article