The tottering nature of the U.S. air traffic control (ATC) system was highlighted again last week when the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) issued a "ground stop," halting flights across the country because of technical issues. The government is attributing the problem to equipment problems, which is believable for a long-obsolete, government-run system undergoing piecemeal modernization. In fact, the FAA had been warned that disruptions were likely. After repeated problems, sometimes caused by government shutdowns, it's time to point out once more that the U.S. should follow the lead of other countries and strip politicians of responsibility for something as important as air traffic control.
The Technical Glitch That Grounded a Nation
According to the FAA, last Friday, "the FAA's legacy equipment became unstable when data began flooding the FAA FTI network, at a rate of 1,000 connection attempts every 4 to 5 seconds. This disrupted the system and created instability with aircraft communications and radar feeds."
The agency went on to deny that its ongoing efforts to upgrade the aging system are at fault, but Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy added that the problem occurred while L3Harris, a government contractor, "was replacing an old copper wire, which by the way, was going to be discontinued," and when a recently replaced router was turned back on, it flooded the system with data.
The ground stop isn't really a surprise. Air traffic control in the U.S. has stuttered in the past, most recently when last year's government shutdown left many federal workers laboring for delayed paychecks—and some air traffic controllers calling in sick. In 2023, a technical glitch in the system caused the delay and cancellation of thousands of flights. The creaky system has caused worries for years, inspiring modernization efforts. Just two weeks ago, Duffy boasted that the FAA is finally retiring 1980s-era floppy disks. But the upgrade program also causes concerns.
Decades of Failed Modernization Efforts
"We agree with the need to significantly accelerate the modernization of these ATC systems and applaud FAA's initial progress. However, in the interest of expediency, FAA is introducing additional risk," the Government Accountability Office (GAO) warned just two months ago. "In essence, the FAA is buying delivery speed at the risk of cost uncertainty and potential disruptions. The net effect could be that air traffic controllers are forced to continue to rely on severely outdated systems that are prone to failure leading to more system outages, ground stops, flight delays, or worse—safety incidents."
Unfortunately, government isn't good at slow and steady upgrades either. In 2005, the GAO cautioned that "the Federal Aviation Administration's (FAA) multibillion-dollar effort to modernize the nation's air traffic control (ATC) system has suffered from cost, schedule, and/or performance shortfalls in its system acquisitions for more than two decades and has been on our list of high risk programs since 1995."
And here we are. After decades of increasingly serious glitches, warnings, and ambitious upgrade plans, the air traffic control system still teeters on the edge of failure, and it just tipped over the edge—although temporarily. There must be a better way. In fact, there is.
Learn From Other Countries and Privatize Air Traffic Control
"Today, roughly 100 countries receive their air traffic control services from user-funded utilities. Australia, Canada, Germany, and the U.K. all have newer, more-advanced technology than our Federal Aviation Administration (FAA), and all of them are self-funded and independent of government budgets," Robert Poole of the Reason Foundation, which publishes Reason, wrote last November.
Poole and his colleagues have worked on the ATC issue for years, calling repeatedly for depoliticization and more private sector involvement. In July of this year, industry consultant John Kefaliotis wrote for the Reason Foundation that "Canada provides a working model of a successful transition from a tax-funded air traffic control system chronically short of adequate revenue and long-term financing to a sustainable, adaptable non-profit commercial structure capable of continuous modernization."
Hoover Institution research fellow David R. Henderson, a former adviser to the Reagan administration, agrees with that suggestion. He points out that the then-financially strapped Canadian government divested itself of ATC responsibilities in the 1990s. "In 1996, partly to save money and partly to improve air navigation, the feds sold the system to a private nonprofit company called Nav Canada," he noted after the 2023 U.S. ATC outage. "Almost immediately, Nav Canada acted to upgrade technology. How has Nav Canada performed? Very well."
Henderson pointed to a Reason Foundation study that found "Nav Canada has speeded up modernization, dramatically increased efficiency and productivity, and cut user fees by one-third."
Chris Edwards of the Cato Institute also likes that model. In 2024, he emphasized that "the privatized Canadian system has won numerous international awards and is a leader in many technologies. Canada and Europe are ahead of us, for example, on remote or digital towers, which surround runways with cameras and sensors to feed large video screens in control buildings."
A History of Frustrated Reform Efforts
Various flavors of ATC privatization have been on the table before. The Reagan administration considered the idea, and the Clinton administration floated a proposal for spinning it off into a user-funded corporation. Under the first Trump administration, then-House Transportation and Infrastructure Committee Chairman Bill Shuster (R–Penn.) pushed for a Canadian-style ATC system separate from the government. He dropped it under pressure from entrenched interests.
"Despite an unprecedented level of support for this legislation—from bipartisan lawmakers, industry, and conservative groups and labor groups alike—some of my own colleagues refused to support shrinking the federal government by 35,000 employees, cutting taxes, and stopping wasteful spending," Shuster said at the time. He left Congress in 2019, though he continues to favor privatization.
Shuster's failed effort was the last serious attempt to reform air traffic control rather than prop up the decaying government scheme. After last week's ground stop, Duffy asked for an additional $50 billion to, hopefully, get the long-delayed modernization effort completed.
Maybe the U.S. government will finally succeed at making government a competent manager of air traffic control—a sensitive responsibility over which other governments have surrendered, one after another. More likely, we're in for repeated delays, cancellations, and mass disruptions as the government air traffic control system deteriorates until change is forced on resistant politicians.
The post Get Government Out of Air Traffic Control appeared first on Reason Magazine.


Bengali (Bangladesh) ·
English (United States) ·