Differentiation: The Depressing Reason People Act So Toxic Online

1 day ago 1

Rommie Analytics

If you’re seeing a constant slew of “ragebait” (deliberately divisive and provocative content) on your social media feed, you might chalk it up to the algorithm.

After all, we know that anger and negativity are really effective ways to get all-important attention, which can make creators and social media sites a lot of money.

But there’s another side to the equation here, a new paper from PNAS argues. Even when the systems that may push negative content to the fore are absent, it theorises, “differentiation” can turn single-topic online spaces sour regardless. 

What is “differentiation”? 

As the word suggests, it’s about being different from other people. 

After analysing an eye-watering 2.05 billion comments from 2,150 Reddit communities, researchers noticed that in general, the longer a topic is discussed online, the less positive the discourse seemed to become. 

The same is true for communities that have existed for a long time, or comment threads that keep going and going. 

“This is the first time someone has shown that, so that’s a finding in and of itself,” shared Harvard’s Assistant Professor of Psychiatry, Joshua Conrad Jackson, who co-authored the study.

Interestingly, the “more positive a conversation starts, the more negative it will become – because if the thread starts really positive, the positive comments are all taken at the beginning and you have to go negative”. 

The theory suggests that if everyone loved a hit movie or TV show, online commenters would eventually run out of ways to say ‘isn’t this great!’. 

So, in an attempt to stand out, posters might pick apart an element of the popular media, which nobody has commented on before.

And in general, Jackson said, people don’t generally try to differentiate themselves by being uniquely positive. After all, “there are just more negative things to say”.

However, there’s a (slightly funny, in an eye-rolling way) exception. In longer-running threads and online discussions that have become truly toxic, those mentioning the long-forgotten positives could stand back out again.s

This might not only apply to online sites 

Jackson suggested that person-to-person conversations, which often vary in topics, are less likely to fall foul of this negative “differentiation” – once a subject’s been discussed enough, we just move on. 

But some online spaces like fandom forums, or other places which dissect the same topic endlessly, may be especially vulnerable to the proposed effect. 

“Cable news channels with a 24-hour news cycle are a good candidate, because anchors and correspondents are often covering stories for long periods of time with little new information. Under these conditions, there is a risk that discourse turns more negative,” for instance, said Jackson. 

“In contrast, everyday conversations allow us to change topics frequently and avoid this negativity trap. Trying to differentiate oneself isn’t inherently bad. Decades of research suggest that it is a natural human motive.

“However, our study shows that this motive can promote negativity when conversation must stay on a single topic.”

Read Entire Article